• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Sealing & Contamination Control Tips

Fluid Power Sealing and Contamination Control Information and Resources

  • News
  • Contamination Control
  • Filtration
  • Seals
  • Fluids
  • Design Guides
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / Featured / Static versus dynamic seals in fluid power

Static versus dynamic seals in fluid power

October 26, 2023 By Mary Gannon Leave a Comment

Share

By Josh Cosford, Contributing Editor

Let’s square off in a squared circle to discuss why dynamic seals are never square. I suppose one could manufacture a square seal, but perhaps that would be more of a gasket. Either way, we’re pitting static seals against dynamic seals to see who comes out on top, and you may find yourself surprised by the victor.

static versus dynamic seals AdobeStock_205788944

As you’ve probably figured out, static seals remain stationary while dynamic seals move (or are exposed to movement). Static seals find themselves used to seal two components or two areas, such as cylinder barrel end seals, pump flanges seals or spool-valve end-cap seals. Static seals are manufactured from most rubber and plastic materials, ranging from soft Buna Nitrile to hard Teflon. Like all choices in the fluid power world, seals should be chosen specifically for the application.

Viton is excellent for high-temperature applications or those with specifically dangerous fluids such as phosphate ester but is limited in high-pressure capacity. Conversely, Teflon provides superior high-pressure resistance due to its extrusion resistance but sometimes requires replacing every time the part is opened up or serviced.

Static seals will perform handily up to 30,000 psi (2,070 bar) without failure with the correct seal compound, pocket design and tolerances. Some seal material, such as NBR, pretty much turns to jelly as pressure forces the material into every micron of surface area behind it. As a result, and so long as the extrusion gaps (Figure 1) are minimal, the seal cannot squirm its way between two surfaces. The higher the pressure or, the bigger the gap, the more likely extrusion is to occur in static applications.

Figure 1. Extrusion gap
Figure 1. Extrusion gap

Dynamic seals require much more forethought because they count on much more than well-engineering cavities to operate effectively. Pressure-related extrusion combines with friction to create unique problems with dynamic seals. Even under low pressure, a dynamic seal could still extrude because the velocity-related friction tucks the seal through the extrusion gap, which is why dynamic seals are rated by maximum velocity.

Interference-fit seals, such as loaded T-seal, O-rings or other exotic designs, offer fantastic pressure and load-holding capacity. Still, because the seal is larger than the diameter sealed against, friction limits velocity. An O-ring with two backup washers may allow only 1.5-3.0 ft/sec velocity, and even many U-cup seals aren’t much better because they’re also loaded out the outer edge.

With dynamic seals, there is no magic bullet – leak-free seals carry the high-friction penalty, while high-velocity designs must yield some sealing capacity in favor of low-friction. PFTE crown seals with loaded energizers give designers 12 ft/sec or more. But the ultimate in velocity comes from no sealing at all. Cast iron piston rings or a combination using PTFE wear rings support the piston, but you could move the piston rod assembly freely by hand, and it offers no load-holding capacity whatsoever. Just brute force and high flow allow these cylinders to traverse as quickly as desired (within reason).

After the bell rings, who wins this bout? I’m sure you’ve figured out that the judges have called a draw. Static and dynamic seals both provide legitimate options for differing applications, and most hydraulic components employ both.

 

You may also like:

  • Piston rubber seal on a pneumatic cylinder
    How do you select pneumatic cylinder seals?
  • Cylinder piston seals AdobeStock_25655813
    What is the best cylinder piston seal?
  • Example of a seal extruded over some time
    What are seal extrusion gaps?
  • COG Vi 900 FKM elastomer seals for oil and gas
    When should you use Viton seals?

  • Basics of static sealing

Filed Under: Featured, Seals

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Fluid Power World Digital Editions

Fluid Power World Digital Edition

Browse the most current issue of Fluid Power World and back issues in an easy to use high quality format. Bookmark, share and interact with the leading design engineering magazine today.

Fluid Power Design Guides

fluid
“sact
EXPAND YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND STAY CONNECTED
Get the latest info on technologies, tools and strategies for Fluid Power Professionals.

Footer

Sealing and Contamination Tips

Fluid Power World Digital Network

  • Fluid Power World
  • Mobile Hydraulic Tips
  • Pneumatic Tips
  • Hose Assembly Tips
  • Leadership in Engineering

Sealing & Contamination Control

  • Subscribe to Fluid Power World
  • Videos
  • Advertise with us
  • About us

Copyright © 2025 · WTWH Media, LLC · Privacy Policy